The Old City Hall properties ("Site") are addressed 202 North Alabama and 222 North Alabama Street. 202 North Alabama is the location of the Old City Hall building, and 222 North Alabama Street is a vacant parking lot ("Sites").

The Old City Hall parcel (local parcel #1097670) is 0.66 acres. The parcel is occupied entirely by the historic Old City Hall. The building is four floors and a basement, with a total floor area of ~85,000 square feet. Constructed in 1909 – 1910, the building was used for City offices until 1962, after which it was used for the Indiana State Museum and later for the Indianapolis Central Library.

The 222 North Alabama parcel (local parcel #1029552) is a 0.65-acre surface parking lot adjacent to the Old City Hall parcel and building.

The City of Indianapolis invites proposals that provide a mix of housing and commercial/retail activity for the underutilized surface parking lot, proposals that would preserve and repurpose the Old City Hall building, and proposals that would seek to redevelop both properties. Responses should contemplate street-level activation and development that harmonizes with and builds off adjacent development and districts. Proposals should be sensitive to the historic preservation plan for both properties.