Dec. 19, 2024
The start of a new year often brings with it the promise of a better tomorrow, both personally and professionally. Why not take that resolution to heart in 2025 by making some time for yourself. Cozy up in a comfortable chair, tune out the noise and distractions, and lower your stress levels while furthering your knowledge by checking out these new books featured in the Journal of the American Planning Association (JAPA).
Stay in-the-know
These page-turners touch on some of the most pressing topics impacting planning today. After reading each brief synopsis here, click through to read the full JAPA review, which is available to nonsubscribers for a limited time. A special thanks goes to our JAPA reviewers: Erick Guerra, John Landis, Elizabeth Mueller, and Deni Ruggeri.
Our recommended books are:
Killed by a Traffic Engineer: Shattering the Delusion That Science Underlies Our Transportation System
Wes Marshall, 2024, Island Press, 344 pp, $35
Although improving traffic safety is the top stated priority of the federal and many state departments of transportation, the U.S. has the highest traffic fatality rate of its wealthy democratic peers. In 88 short, punchy chapters, Wes Marshall — a licensed professional engineer and civil engineering professor — provides plenty of evidence of how, rather than science, the traffic engineering profession relies on a host of manuals and practices developed on shaky research or pure conjecture over the past century. He likens contemporary traffic engineering to the early days of medicine when doctors and other practitioners likely killed as many patients as they saved.
By tracing a host of practices, Marshall convincingly shows that much of what traffic engineers claim improves safety is uncertain, contested, and synonymous with increasing capacity. I highly recommend it for anyone who cares about traffic safety or wants examples of how poor practices can become embedded in the daily practices of institutions.
Read the full JAPA review by Erick Guerra, University of Pennsylvania.
Poverty, By America
Matthew Desmond, 2023, Penguin Random House, 320 pp, $20
In Poverty, By America, Matthew Desmond takes a broad and complex issue and attempts to distill it into a concise message. In short, Desmond argues that poverty persists because we all benefit from it. While this is not a new argument, he updates evidence of the degradation of jobs at the low end of the labor market and the ways people experiencing poverty — particularly Black Americans — are preyed upon and overpay for essential items like housing and access to cash and credit. Government is part of the problem — and so is the growing aversion that many U.S. residents have to use services we associate with the underserved, which reinforces resistance to investing in it.
Desmond proposes bold solutions and his arguments are particularly relevant for planners. This ambitious book is ultimately about building a new narrative about poverty, our role in it, and our obligation to act as a powerful diagnosis of our complicity in maintaining poverty.
Read the full JAPA review by Elizabeth Mueller, University of Texas at Austin.
How Big Things Get Done: The Surprising Factors That Determine the Fate of Every Project, From Home Renovations to Space Exploration and Everything in Between
Bent Flyvbjerg and Dan Gardner, 2023, Crown Currency, 304 pp, $28.99
One of the ways planning differs from other task-oriented professions is in how it learns from success and failure. As in previous books, Bent Flyvbjerg encourages urban planners, project managers, and the agencies that fund large-scale projects to be more realistic in their goals, cautious in their projections, and humble in their methods.
Drawing on past and present-day projects — ranging from Terminal 5 at London's Heathrow Airport and high-speed rail in California to an initially modest home renovation in Brooklyn that ended up costing six times the estimate — Flyvbjerg and Gardner deliver a series of concise lessons on how to improve the odds of undertaking successful projects. They show readers that the most important tools in any project management toolkit are experience, a healthy skepticism of optimistic forecasts and the latest-and-greatest technologies, an ability to manage teams, and an understanding of risk sources.
Read the full JAPA review by John Landis, University of Pennsylvania.
The Shape of Utopia: The Architecture of Radical Reform in Nineteenth-Century America
Irene Cheng, 2023, University of Minnesota Press, 376 pp, $35 paper
Narrated as an epic novel, impeccably researched, and richly rendered, The Shape of Utopia: The Architecture of Radical Reform in Nineteenth-Century America takes a much-deserved place among planning history classics. It is a masterfully comprehensive account of intertwining the personal and landscape biographies of 19th-century American reformists, their social visions of communitarianism and social coexistence, and their mixed attempts at prototyping them. Far from being old-fashioned, distant stories, Cheng extracts from the past critical lessons for today's planners related to epistemology, representation, standardization, communication, authorship, and responsibility for planning choices.
Read the full JAPA review by Deni Ruggeri, University of Maryland.